Ninth Circuit Court Updates – CARB SB 253/261

On November 9, 2026, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit (Ninth Circuit) released an opinion for publication in the United States of America Chamber of Commerce, et al. v. Sanchez, et al (Case No. 25-5327). The Ninth Circuit delivered major news and returned a split judgement regarding the California Corporate Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program being developed under the Climate Corporate Data Accountability Act [Senate Bill (SB) 253] and Climate-Related Financial Risk Program of SB 261. The opinion stated that the Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosures required under SB 253 were considered commercial speech and the reporting was allowed to proceed, while the Scope 3 disclosures under SB 253 and the climate-related disclosures under SB 261 were not commercial speech, and are likely unconstitutional.

Background

In November of 2025, the Ninth Circuit issued an order to grant an injunction against the enforcement of SB 261 under Case No. 25-5327. In a December 2025 enforcement advisory, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) stated that in light of that order, it would not enforce the Health and Safety Code (HSC) section 38533 against covered entities who failed to submit their SB 261 reports by the statutory deadline of January 1, 2026. However, entities could choose to voluntarily report at this time using an open docket for submittals.

Regarding SB 253, codified in HSC 38532, the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) approved the Initial Regulation covering the first-year reports on October 12, 2026, with the first-year reports due on November 10, 2026. The first-year reports that were due earlier in November only required Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions reporting, and CARB is exercising its enforcement discretion that it will not require assurance verification. CARB was still working through developing the requirements and regulation for 2027 and future year reporting, which was set to include Scope 3 and assurance verifications, and recently provided updates to the CARB board members on updates in their process. Check out ALL4’s blog on the October 2026 board meeting to see what updates CARB had proposed.

What Does the Ninth Circuit Decision Mean?

The main arguments presented in the ruling were around the commercial speech arguments. For the Scope 1 and Scope 2 portions of SB 253, the Ninth Circuit’s opinion stated that because the information on greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions is directly related to a company’s operations, this information is important, and factual, and directly tied to a company, and it meets the commercial speech arguments. However, for Scope 3 GHG emissions, because those emissions are tied to data from other companies both upstream and downstream from the reporting entity, its relation to the company and its mandatory reporting is not commercial speech, and the district court will have to evaluate this portion of the SB 253 regulation. Similarly, the SB 261 climate-related risk disclosures were said to be judgements (as compared to the factual basis that was Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions under SB 253) because they involve “predictive and normative judgements about future economic conditions and a politically fraught subject” (page 8 of the opinion) and not commercial speech.

Therefore, the Ninth Circuit affirmed the district court’s denial of the preliminary injunction regarding SB 253 Scope 1 and Scope 2 disclosure requirements, while reversing the denial of a preliminary injunction on SB 253’s Scope 3 disclosure requirement and SB 261 in its entirety. The Ninth Circuit also remanded this case to the district court to determine whether the Scope 3 disclosure issue can be severed or separated from the rest of the SB 253 regulation.

Because this is a preliminary injunction ruling from the initial district court case, and has been remanded back to the district court, this was just an opinion and not a final judgement. Both parties may seek a rehearing within 14 days of the opinion or may petition for the case to be heard by the United States Supreme Court.

Conclusion and Next Steps

The November 10, 2026, deadline for the first year of submittal of reports containing disclosures of Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions for SB 253 has now passed. CARB has not provided public comment on the Ninth Circuit’s decision, nor has it published its plan for 2027 and future year rulemaking. The SB 261 portal remains open for companies who elect to voluntarily report, but the case remains open, so no reporting requirement has changed from a legal perspective at this time. ALL4 recommends that companies who may need to report (depending on the outcomes of the legal challenges) continue to track Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions information and stay tuned for updates on verification requirements to be published by CARB.

ALL4 will continue to monitor CARB progress on developing future regulations including potential future public workshops and press release(s) regarding legal updates for SB 253 or SB 261. We will continue to follow the case as it goes back to the district court. ALL4 has staff experienced in preparing GHG emissions inventories and evaluating regulatory applicability. If you need help evaluating either SB 253 or SB 261 requirements, preparing your report(s), calculating Scope 1, 2, or 3 emissions, or if you have follow-up questions or comments regarding these latest updates, please reach out to Corey Prigent at cprigent@all4inc.com.

Subscribe to 4 the Record

Sign up to receive 4 THE RECORD articles here. You’ll get timely articles on current environmental, health, and safety regulatory topics as well as updates on webinars and training events.